Last month, I had quite the disturbing incident at a local bank. I had gone in to redeem a certificate of deposit that had come due. At some banks, this is not a big deal. You go up to a teller window, give them your ID and paperwork, and they type up a cashier's check and you are out the door in less than 10 minutes.Unfortunately, this trend is going by the wayside in favor of "personal banking." Personal bankers are people in the banking industry trained to harass customers into giving out personal financial details and preferences and calling you at home with the excuse that they are "just checking to see if there's anything you need." And NO, I do not want to open another checking account! I hate personal bankers.
Back to the story.........I enter this branch where they insist that you sit down in a little cubicle with a personal banker if you want to redeem your CD. I sat around in the lobby waiting for a personal banker to get off the phone, while three tellers stood around twiddling their thumbs. Once the personal banker had time for me, her first question was, "What are you going to do with the money?" I tried my best to say, "None of your damned business" in the nicest way possible, but when that didn't work, I told the truth. I was going to another bank with better interest rates. Like they don't know that! She then proceeded to attempt to talk me out of it. She tried to guess what bank I was going to (I wouldn't reveal that) and then used scare tactics with details about the poor financial situations of other banks in our area. Umm Lady........just give me my money! When she saw I wasn't going to budge, she said that she'd be right back with my check and then she left me alone. I was seething as this had already wasted 15 minutes of my time. Little did I know.........
A few minutes later, a slick young man entered the cubicle and feigned friendliness with a handshake and introduction. He then began his own pressure tactics with all these facts and figures about what great financial shape his bank was in and why in the world would I want to take my money elsewhere? At this point, I was getting kind of nervous. This three-piece suit resembled mafia intimidation to my overactive imagination. I finally told him I wasn't the least bit concerned about putting my money somewhere else because wasn't there a little thing called the FDIC?? That didn't stop him. He told me my money could be tied up for DECADES if a bank went under. I stood my ground and told him I'd take my chances. With barely a nod goodbye, he stormed off, perhaps in pursuit of another customer.
I waited around another 10 minutes until personal banker lady came back with my check. I don't know if she thought I'd give up and leave without my money or if she was trying to round up more troops to surround me and my fat purse. I pried the check out her hands and did my own storming out.
Since then, I have told everyone I know about my experience with this bank, including other banks I like, just so they get the hint that customers do not appreciate these methods. I will never return to that bank, even if their interest rates on deposits go up to 15%. And now I'm kind of hoping a personal banker from that bank will call me so I can tell him/her that.
Wow, I guess I've been spoiled by my parish-based credit union, where all the 'personal bankers' are folks I see in church every Sunday, and they're much more likely to burn 15 minutes of my time (and theirs) talking about our kids. . .
ReplyDeletethat's ridiculous. i'd be more than a wee tad annoyed by such pressure tactics.
ReplyDeleteSome years ago we had a bank or two that engaged in similar tactics. Both times I faced it I was fortunate to have other 'assets' with the banks. When Slick-boy walked in I requested an audience with the bank mangler and then proceded to liquidate everything with the bank, making it clear to the mangler it was in 'retaliation' for shabby treatment.
ReplyDeleteBut folks around here are like that and the practice (and one of the banks) disappeared rather quickly. We've been banking almost exclusively with a local credit union since.
Sorry they wasted your time.
I would be compelled to call the bank daily to tell them how awesome my new bank was, but encouarge them not to take it personally.
ReplyDeleteOy. I'm glad that my bank hasn't resorted to that. Of course I do most of my banking online (that has its own perils).
ReplyDeleteI would be so irritated!! Good for you to stand your ground, I hate it when they ask you what you what you plan to do with your money.
ReplyDeleteI'm afraid I would've gone all snarky on them when they asked what I was doing with the money, and depending on my mood would have used one of the following answers:
ReplyDelete*Taking a round the world cruise to celebrate not having to deal with your bank anymore.
*Investing in my own personal homeland security measures for my home, and I suggest you do likewise. (said with a bit of a wild crazy look in my eyes)
*I don't know. What do you do with your money when you have $X to spare?
*[standing and speaking loudly enough to be heard throughout the room] Why are you trying to intimidate me? Why won't you give me my money? What is wrong with you people?
But then again, I'm just a wiseass who can't resist causing problems for people like that.
DId you have any other accounts with them? Because I'd threaten to close that if they didn't ease up. I HATE that sort of thing.
ReplyDeleteWhat a pain in the ass!!
ReplyDeleteGood for you for standing your ground.
ReplyDeleteI guess I'm lucky that we have so little money that our banks (credit union these days) have never seemed to care much about it. I'm a money-loser for them, as I'm not giving them much to invest with!
ReplyDeleteIt sure was nice of them to be so concerned about your money's well-being though, wasn't it? Such thoughtful people.
Desmond - I need one of those.
ReplyDeleteLime - It was a tad scary too.
Xavier - I was glad to not have any other accounts there, but that would have been my idea of retaliation as well.
FADKOG - I'm not a phone caller, but if I could do that via e-mail, I would!
Russ - I've tried on-line banking and it was too many passwords and codes for me to keep straight.
Jody - Isn't that the nosiest thing ever?
True - If I wasn't afraid of the security cameras, I'd be all for some of those suggestions.
ReplyDeleteCitizen - Fortunately, that was my only account there.
Buttafly - Your response made me burst out laughing - YES IT WAS! Can you imagine if I would have had kids with me??
Mama - Thank you.
FTN - Personal Bankers are now below used car salesmen in my eyes.
Sometimes I think it's a crime that we've all been brought up to be so polite to people who clearly are wasting our time.
ReplyDeleteBollocks.
I work in a bank and I can not believe that story. No really, how could that have happened? I'm going to assume this was a "well known" bank, and not a regional bank. Sorry from all us "good banking" employees...
ReplyDeleteFlutter - It is hard to go against how we were brought up.
ReplyDeleteMike - Local bank. I'm not sure we even have any national banks here anymore.
Sheesh, when did used car salesmen start working as bankers???
ReplyDeleteDang!