. . . . That is the question. I was recently invited to join an established book club. My previous book club lasted for about five years. Unfortunately, we had to disband due to lack of interest. The ladies slowly stopped reading the books and were just showing up to chit chat. As our children grew older, it was harder and harder to find an evening that worked out for everyone. Sadly, it just fell apart.So when another friend invited me to her next book club meeting, I was excited about the new prospect. I diligently read the book, The Last Lecture, and was anxious to meet this new group of women, most of whom I'd never met before. My first shock was the food. My previous group just served wine and appetizers. I was a bit stunned to arrive at the hostess house and find a sit down dinner served on china. Whoa.....seemed sort of high brow to me. I attempted to join in the conversation here and there, but mostly just concentrated on eating my meal as politely as possible and having good table manners.
When the book conversation started, I was pleased to learn that everyone actually read the book. However, it was a bit of a shocker to have the first person drop the F bomb into her first comment. Huh? I really couldn't recall anything in The Last Lecture worthy of any sort of profanity. Kind of odd. But what was most disconcerting was my inability to join into the discussion in any meaningful way. This was a a group of very outspoken ladies. I couldn't squeeze in a word edge-wise. Every time I started to say something, someone else was attempting the same thing and it turned into a, "No, you go ahead." Have you ever been a part of a group like this? I eventually gave up and just sat and listened.
As ladies will do, the conversation turned to sex.......I have no clue how it happened. The women were all in their 40's and only one of them had been to a sex toy party, so she was describing that. Some were asking what different toys were. Others were talking about a sex survey that said that the average married couple has sex 1-2 times/week and they seemed surprised by how high that number was?? Then the talk turned to Brazilian waxes. Most of them were shocked to hear that there were people who were hairless down there. I just continued to keep my mouth shut. I think I live in a different world than a lot of people my age.
So, they meet again in another month and the book is The Shack. Truthfully, I have no desire to read the book, even though it is probably the hottest book out there right now, for the same reason I didn't want to read The Lovely Bones. I just don't want to imagine mine or anyone else's child being brutally murdered. To each his own.
Should I give the group another shot? Or should I gracefully bow out? Let me just say, the women were very gracious and welcoming to me. Maybe I just miss the old familiarity of my previous group? Or maybe I truly just don't fit in?
Oh, I just find it frustrating as hell when I'm in a group where everyone is trying to talk all at once. . .
ReplyDeleteI'd give it one more shot, but if you're still uncomfortable after that, I think I'd drop it.
ReplyDeleteI agree with Mama Dawg, I think you should give it another try. I have been in a similar situation and found after a few tries I felt more comfortable and was able to assert my opinion in the conversation. If it still feels like it's not for you then drop it.
ReplyDeleteWell, I think you should start your OWN book club & establish the outline of how it works (china vs. hors d'oeuvres), how often it meets & all of that! =)
ReplyDeleteYou could invite friends or put up a sign-up list at your church or other place you frequent. Just my opinion.
Desmond - It IS frustrating. I have a few people who talk 100 miles/hr. on the phone and I just interupt them.
ReplyDeleteMama - Sounds fair enough.
Jody - If the book was something more enjoyable, I'd be leaning towards just giving it another go. I need to think about it.
LB - I actually did try to start a new book club once, but I couldn't find enough people to commit to reading one book per month. Maybe I should make it an annual club or something!
You know, I used to participate in a group that read the works of the Early Christian Fathers (roughly, 2nd-thru-7th centuries; we called ourselves the Dead Theologians Society). We would meet every other week, to discuss maybe a 20-30 page section of the book we were working thru. So we'd only do 2-3 books/year. But 20-30 pages is plenty of theology to read/discuss in one session. . .
ReplyDeleteI second your thought on how you don't wish to read the book they've chosen for their next meeting. It's not my cup of tea or glass of wine, either, and honestly, it's one of those that that can make me cringe because of how it becomes 'THE book.' I love when small, lesser read books are the fascinating choices.
ReplyDeleteI suppose I also go along with giving it another try, but after what you experienced, were it me, I'm not sure I would be able to go in as open minded as is necessary to see if it's a good fit. It's hard to give up something that had worked well for so long and find the niche somewhere else, especially when you want to talk about the point at hand!
And maybe it was just this host? Maybe the next hostess will swing back to snacks and sipping?
ReplyDeletei think given that the experience was less than pleasant and the next book not only is not appealing to you but kind of repulsive i'd probably bow out gracefully.
ReplyDeleteTruthfully, nothing about the afternoon you described sounds like anything I'd want to join... but then, I can be a bit of a Scrooge.
ReplyDeleteOutside of the book selection and china and conversational gaffes, it sounds like you don't have much in common with these ladies. I think you'll do better to put your efforts into a book club where you'll end up sharing your insights and opinions with FRIENDS and not just a group of ladies you don't really click with.
I belonged to a reading club once but no one would ever do the reading. But at least it turned into a fun talking, walking, skiing club!
ReplyDeleteDesmond - Ok, now THAT'S high brow!
ReplyDeleteFADKOG - We need our own book discussion group where we bash the books we hate.
Laggin - No, my friend said they always put on a big spread. I can't live up to those sorts of expectations!
Lime - Yeah, I think it might be best to fade away rather than show up one more time.
Flutter - Not even the sex talk sounded all that interesting, did it?
Citizen - Well, my last group attempted to become a Xmas Cookie Exchange group, but I wasn't falling for it!
I am with you on this....your group has to be an exact fit to share books. maybe this one isn't the one for you!
ReplyDelete