My son is about as tight lipped as a teenage boy can be when it comes to school. We hear nothing. I often rely on my friends to inform me about current school gossip, etc. So, it came as a shock yesterday when my son comes home and says he had something really 'wack' to tell me..........he said, and I quote, "Some kid at school had a sex change operation!"
My first thought was, "In the middle of a school year? How is that possible? Spring break is still a few weeks away!"
My second thought was, "My son clearly doesn't know what the hell he's talking about."
I began to pepper him with questions, such as 'Does the boy have boobs now?' Alll my son really knew is that he saw the boy wearing a short skirt and a purple, 'sparkly' blouse. His legs weren't shaved and he was wearing boys tennis shoes (not heels!) My son had no idea if the boy had on makeup or a bra or a purse or anything else. I don't think he wanted to stare. He overheard some kids at lunch say that the boy, formerly known as Kyle, now wanted to be called Katie, and that he had a new facebook page explaining everything.
Well, I immediately looked him/her up! 'Katie' explained how she was going to be doing hormone replacement therapy for 3-5 years and then have an operation. The only other thing on her wall were links to videos such as 'Mom won't relent to gender change!'
Since my son is not an Oprah viewer, he didn't really understand any of it..........and probably didn't want to. I told him it was unlikely that any doctor would perform surgery on someone under 21, but that maybe if the parents had agreed, he really would be taking hormones to change some of his male characteristics, etc.
I asked Middle Child if she knew the boy, since he was only a year behind her in school. She told me she had been in speech therapy with him in 5th grade. On a whim, I looked him up in the yearbook, and he looked as though he possibly had some sort of disability, though I really have no clue. It's sad to me and I hope no one is making fun of him. My son didn't seem to think anyone was making a big deal about it, at least not out in the open. I can't imagine how teachers are dealing with the name change, etc. Fortunately, most seniors are done with phys.ed. and wouldn't be using the locker rooms unless they play a sport.
These are not situations I ever came across in high school!
My first thought was, "In the middle of a school year? How is that possible? Spring break is still a few weeks away!"
My second thought was, "My son clearly doesn't know what the hell he's talking about."
I began to pepper him with questions, such as 'Does the boy have boobs now?' Alll my son really knew is that he saw the boy wearing a short skirt and a purple, 'sparkly' blouse. His legs weren't shaved and he was wearing boys tennis shoes (not heels!) My son had no idea if the boy had on makeup or a bra or a purse or anything else. I don't think he wanted to stare. He overheard some kids at lunch say that the boy, formerly known as Kyle, now wanted to be called Katie, and that he had a new facebook page explaining everything.
Well, I immediately looked him/her up! 'Katie' explained how she was going to be doing hormone replacement therapy for 3-5 years and then have an operation. The only other thing on her wall were links to videos such as 'Mom won't relent to gender change!'
Since my son is not an Oprah viewer, he didn't really understand any of it..........and probably didn't want to. I told him it was unlikely that any doctor would perform surgery on someone under 21, but that maybe if the parents had agreed, he really would be taking hormones to change some of his male characteristics, etc.
I asked Middle Child if she knew the boy, since he was only a year behind her in school. She told me she had been in speech therapy with him in 5th grade. On a whim, I looked him up in the yearbook, and he looked as though he possibly had some sort of disability, though I really have no clue. It's sad to me and I hope no one is making fun of him. My son didn't seem to think anyone was making a big deal about it, at least not out in the open. I can't imagine how teachers are dealing with the name change, etc. Fortunately, most seniors are done with phys.ed. and wouldn't be using the locker rooms unless they play a sport.
These are not situations I ever came across in high school!

Me, either. . .
ReplyDeleteThe daughter of friends of ours, who was a good friend of 1F growing up, did the same thing, altho she did it older, when she was already in her 20s. Took the hormone therapy, started growing a beard, got her breasts amputated, her voice changed, the whole bit.
She had some obvious 'gender' issues, relating to her parents' divorce when she was around 3yo - 'if I had been a boy, maybe Dad wouldn't have left' kind of stuff. She spent several years in a lesbian relationship before going ahead with the hormones/surgery.
It just makes me very sad. And I don't think it's settled things for her as much as she'd hoped, either; but I wouldn't really know that for sure. . .
Of course, there's no way to 'really' turn a man into a woman, or vice versa. Our friend still hasn't got a Y chromosome in her body, and the kid at your son's school still has one in every cell of his. And there's no such thing as a really functional 'fake vagina', even if he does have to sit to pee. And a 'fake penis' all the moreso. No testicles, no ovaries - none of the things that make our genitals 'genital'. All the 'sex-changes' are purely cosmetic (altho I can certainly acknowledge the psychological ramifications of cosmetic changes). . .
It's just very sad. All you can do is wish them well, and hope they find some of what they're looking for. . .
Wow. I can't imagine how hard that would be to deal with in the middle of the school year! For everyone.
ReplyDeleteThings used to seem so much simpler.
oh I hope she's going to be OK, doesn't sound like the parents are much support based on the Facebook entry
ReplyDeleteI came by to tell you how much I love the woodpecker shot on Ron's blog
Very interesting topic!
ReplyDeleteI actually posted about this same topic on my blog a few years ago.
You're right, this is not something I ever came across in high school either. Back then, people didn't even discuss this type of thing. However, I think it's cool that kids nowadays are openly talking about this because it's a part of life.
I actually work with a woman who was once a man, and out of all the transgenders I have ever met in my life (and I've met a lot), she is the most comfortable with herself. When you're in her presence, you actually FEEL that she's a woman. You can't even tell that she was once a man.
She had her operation very young (23 years old), and both her parents were very supportive of her. But I know this is not always the case.
Again, great post topic! Thank you for bringing it to light.
Have a faaaaaabulous weekend, my friend!
X
Gosh, it must've taken huge guts to just suddenly "come out" like that, particularly being at such a young age. No, I never knew of such things at all when I was at school, either.
ReplyDeleteI hear what you say about usually feeling like your pulling teeth, trying to get any snippets of news back from your son about school - mine are the same (smile). The other month, my youngest surprised me by telling me her good friend (a year above her) whom we car-pool with, came out and told her she is gay, and is dating a mutual friend of theirs. Abby was speechless, because her friend didn't fit the butch stereo type she assumed a lesbian must be. We had a really long discussion out of it, and I'm proud to say they are still as much the best of friends as ever.
I don't know if times have changed, but attitudes are - thank goodness!
Never had anything like this to discuss with my kids when they went to school. I think my son told me a year or two ago that alot of kids were listing themselves as 'bi' regarding relationships but whether they were really open to that or not, I don't know.
ReplyDeleteIt must be really difficult to go through something like that in high school. Hope he finds his way with it all and has good support.
Once again, what Craig said about so-called sex-changes. Nobody can change sex, they can only change their appearance to look like the other sex (and even then, not always convincingly). There's certainly a lot less prejudice about it nowadays, and it seems like her schoolmates are being supportive. Whether it's the right thing for him/her to do is another matter, but from what I've read the vast majority of transsexuals feel much happier after they've made the switch.
ReplyDeleteThe subject never came up when I was at school either! It was still a problem that stayed firmly in the closet.
Craig - Your thoughts and feelings are quite parallel to my own. Have never personally known anyone to do this and the Chaz Bono thing is the only reason I actually know anything about it.
ReplyDeleteMe - I can't imagine either. And I asked a teacher friend of mine and she wondered about the bathroom situation at school.
Dianne - Not sure about the parents of the kid; the videos posted could have just been because he/she is interested in the topic and not a reflection on his/her own experience.
Ron - Wow! That is some personal experience with the subject if you work with a transgendered person on a daily basis! Thanks for stopping by to contribute!
Shrinky - Good for your daughter to stick by her friend! That is what a true friend does.
ReplyDeleteChick - We've seen a lot of the bi business at our high school. I have a feeling a lot of it is for the coolness factor or to just be 'different' (even though it's NOT!)
It's interesting, but I'm glad the kids at school aren't (as far as you have said), being openly nasty... we have a kid at our Church, who is very much going through this- and unfortunately, no support from her dad- in fact, no acknowledgment at all, which is sad.
ReplyDeleteI've known (and work with still) a couple of people that have had to do the transition, and it's hard, I wish the entire family good luck!
Well see now, we had 2 guys and one girl in High School who only dreamed of such things back in the day. Amazing how much of themselves some folks 'get' out of gender identity.
ReplyDeleteI don't know if any of them ever got to change to what they wanted to be but I know none were happy. Period. Gender aside, none of them really seemed to like much of anything.
Nick - I often wonder if people sometimes act happy, after going through all of that. It would be too damned depressing to not be!
ReplyDeleteSailor - That's amazing that you've known more than one person! I'd think it was so rare that not many people would come across it. I know I never have in my 48 years!
X - I think there are those who never find what they are looking for, whether they are looking in the bottom of a bottle, at the top of the corporate ladder, or in this case, in breasts or a vagina!
I'm going to assume that this kid is genuinely transgendered (if not, that's a whole other story). There is only one "treatment" for that - gender reassignment surgery. Which does indeed begin with years of hormone therapy. A kid can't get the surgery done, and in the States it generally takes years to get approval, which is why many transgendered people travel to places like Thailand to receive the surgeries involved. But what people need to understand is that with folks who are truly transgendered, it is not some passing phase. And it is not caused by divorce or other life disruptions. They identify as the other sex from as soon as hey can be aware of gender. They believe with everything in them that they were born into the wrong body. It would be as if you woke up and discovered you were in a man's body. Disturbing, and not in keeping with your identity. The surgical changes are not purely cosmetic. It's true that people who have the operations can't procreate, but lots of "real" men and women can't, either. Also, given that there are chromosomal variations like Turner's Syndrome (a single X), Klinefelter's (XXY) and Triple X(three or more X chromosomes), you can't even pin gender entirely on that. It's a combination of chromosomes, hormones, self-image and almost certainly biological influences like differences in brain functioning and in utero hormonal influences). I've worked with a couple of transgendered people. Sure they have issues - how could they not when they are in the wrong body? But they are not automatically more disturbed than anyone else.
ReplyDeleteSo, all that as a psychologist. As a mother, I hope with all my heart that this kid is supported and taken care of through this journey.
Gender reassignment is at the very least a controversial topic. . .
ReplyDeleteAgent - Thanks for your professional expertise on all of this. The only reason I'm a bit doubtful is when I looked him up in the yearbook....I wasn't expecting an overweight, very masculine looking boy....and then some comments from my daughter. It lends me to think that he could be on the spectrum or have a cognitive delay. And that worries me because those kids are highly susceptible to outside influences, etc. It's not my business, though, but I thought it would make for an interesting discussion.
ReplyDeleteCraig - Apparently!
ReplyDeletewow, it's assuredly a hard situation to be in for an adult. i can't imagine as a teen, when identity is such a fluid and confusing thing to begin with.
ReplyDeletegood point about people never seeming to find what they are looking for. i know many folks who just don't know what it is, but they are certain what they've got already isn't it. i supposed that all is part of our fallen nature, not realizing our 'place' or if realizing, not accepting it. is this all there is? is this all i am and all i am meant to be?
ReplyDeleteYou're right -- times have changed a lot!
ReplyDeleteMy heart goes out to your son's schoolmate... it's a hard road ahead, and as many have said, there is not always happiness found at the end.
But then, that applies to most of life's journeys, doesn't it?