Do Something Naughty: Read A Book

It's Banned Book Week!  What better way to celebrate being an American is there than to read a book from the list?

For those who may not be aware, the American Library Association compiles a list each year of the most challenged books at libraries across the country.  Who is challenging these books, you may ask?  People who count four letter words in a book instead of reading it?  People who think sex is something dirty and should never be mentioned in public?  People who have never passed a reading comprehension exam or understand any literary devices?  People who think they can control their children forever by limiting what they read?

Check out this year's list:  http://libguides.pulaskitech.edu/content.php?pid=67220&sid=2843202

Just a few comments from the list.......I'm amazed that people still fret over To Kill A Mockingbird this many decades after publication.  I'm waiting to see if The Scarlet Letter appears on the list next year.  That one is chock full of mean girls and adultery!

The Absolutely True Diary of A Part-Time Indian.  While I didn't care for this book, as I despise any book that stereotypes people, it IS written by a Native American, and those really ARE his experiences in HIS culture.  Unless his fellow tribe members are the ones complaining, who are we to say his book is racist and offensive?

The one that truly takes the cake is The Hunger Games trilogy.  Anti-family?  Obviously, those people have not opened the book.  It's PRO-FAMILY!  But the real irony is that the books depict what could happen to America in the future, if nutters like book banners take over.

Comments

  1. The reasons for wanting the bans are ridiculous. Nudity? Sexually explicit? Offensive language? Are these people stuck in the 1950s or what? Great idea to publicise all the banned books and the wilful denial of their literary merit.

    ReplyDelete
  2. love the graphic you found to go with it. love that you are marking banned books week too. rock on with your own intellectually free self.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I have been utterly flabbergasted that people want to ban Huckleberry Finn, for my money, the greatest American novel of them all, because it contains the 'N-word'. So it must be racist garbage, right? Talk about never having read the book. . .

    ReplyDelete
  4. You GO, girl!

    And Brava to you for posting this!!!

    I'm beyond flabbergasted about "To Kill A Mockingbird" being on the list!?!? I was actually in the stage production of the play many, many years ago. Yes, it does depict racism as it was back then, but the whole point/moral of the story is to show how WRONG racism is.

    Again, thank you for sharing this post!
    X

    ReplyDelete
  5. Nick - The 'nudity' claim is ridiculous, unless we're talking a comic book....and even then.....

    Lime - Makes you want to go read an obscene book now, doesn't it??

    Craig - Anything by Twain is an American classic, for sure. I do wonder if he meant his books for the ages that it is currently required reading. I re-read Tom Sawyer with Middle Child and chuckled throughout, but don't remember thinking it was funny at all when I was a kid! Nor did my own kids.

    Ron - EXACTLY! People completely miss the point! We learn from history and that book makes a great historical lesson. Glad you liked my post!

    ReplyDelete
  6. Like Ron I am amazed that To Kill A Mockingbird is on the list, I was actually considering buying and reading this one again and after this it is a definite.

    People need to actually read these books and consider the time in which they were written, there is actually a moral to each story that you will not catch if you are only looking for offensive words.

    Excellent Post my Friend

    ReplyDelete
  7. Everytime I hear about this type of moronic reaction to reading material, I can't help think that freedom of expression is wasted on some... okay, I'm kidding...

    The one that really makes me see red though, is a proposal I came across (no link at the moment- and it may have been satirical, but still irked me).. to re-write Huckleberry Finn!

    I heard that a while back, and it instantly became REQUIRED reading, for my kids, so we could actually discuss what was making people react in such a doofy way.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Jimmy - It seems as though some like to just count the bad words and ignore the message. Their loss!

    Sailor - I vaguely remember that. Can you imagine if someone did that to all the classics. Wait, that's called communism!

    ReplyDelete
  9. I'm baffled by the presence of To Kill a Mockingbird too. There is much more offensive literature out there today!

    ReplyDelete
  10. I grew up with "To Kill A Mockingbird" and the injunction against killing songbirds. Atticus Finch always reminded me of my Grandfather, a gentle-souled Southern lawyer himself. And I even had a dog named Atticus.

    Where was I going with all that? I don't know really, just the sad silliness of banning these books. But I remember when they tried to ban "Are You There God? It's Me, Margaret."

    ReplyDelete
  11. Rhonda -Classics like that show up so much because of required reading at school and parents who don't like it.

    Agent - I can't imagine my childhood without Judy Blume.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Hi Bijoux,
    I am kind of surprised that books would still be banned in our day and age.
    Very unfortunate...
    So yah, go read a banned book and decide yourself what is/not bad. Go girl!

    ReplyDelete
  13. First admitting to The Incident in the 80s and now this?? Scandalous! ;)

    ReplyDelete
  14. Flutter - LOL, the 'incident'!!!

    ReplyDelete
  15. Our kids see so much worse on broadcast TV these days.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment