Survey Says . . . . . . I'm A Female!

A few weeks ago, I received a letter in the mail stating that our household had been chosen to participate in a Center for Disease Control phone survey about the public's perception of tobacco.  Because research money needs to be spent on determining whether the public really believes tobacco is unhealthy? I'm more than happy to share my opinion (ha!) and I did appreciate the heads up, otherwise I would have just hung up, thinking it was a solicitor.

If you are like our family, you use caller ID to screen your calls, because the Do Not Call Registry never lived up to its hype.  For some reason, I expected a call from the CDC to come from an official CDC headquarters in Atlanta or Washington, D.C.  Eventually, one of their smart surveyors did leave a message saying they were from the CDC, calling about the survey. This enabled me to look out for a call from Burlington, Vermont (of all places?) and answer the next time they called.

After going through how many people lived here and the number of males vs. females in our household, the surveyor asked to speak with the oldest female; more on this later.  I was told I could refuse to answer any of the questions and she moved along to some rather specific questions: How many cigarettes have I smoked (at least 2 puffs) in my lifetime? It got so specific that I was waiting to be asked the brand name of every cigarette I had ever smoked (but had to be at least 2 puffs!)

She went through the whole litany of my experiences with cigarettes, cigars, chewing tobacco, e-cigarettes, hookahs, and even things I'd never heard of, such as dissolvable tobacco.  Then I had to rate them all based on my opinion: very unhealthy/moderately unhealthy/not unhealthy at all.  No questions, however, about weed!

Just when my patience was beginning to wear thin, she said the final questions were for classification purposes.  Things like race, family income, education.  Then this:

"Were you born a male or female?" (Ok, I'll bite.  Female)
"And do you currently consider yourself a male or female?" (This is when I laughed and said I thought we had covered this at the beginning of the phone call?)

In true "I am from the government and I'm here to help you robot-fashion" she just asked the question again.  I'm wondering how often they come across a transgendered person in their random survey, and what effect they believe it would have on their survey?

Later on, I spoke to my husband on the phone and told him about some of the survey questions.  He said he hoped I'd still be a female by the time he got home.


Comments

  1. " He said he hoped I'd still be a female by the time he got home."

    OMG....I loved that!!!

    "I'm wondering how often they come across a transgendered person in their random survey, and what effect they believe it would have on their survey?"

    Yes, my thoughts exactly. What effect would THAT have on their survey?!?

    To ask if someone was born male or female, and than ask if you currently consider yourself male or female seems like they're going into a completely different survey. Plus, it sounds like a "trick"question - HA!

    Anyway, GREAT post topic!! And yes, I use caller ID to screen my calls. I love caller ID!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The funny thing is that I do online surveys daily to earn money through a number of different sites and I have never seen that as a classification question. The times they are a changing!

      Delete
  2. Well .. so, were you?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Good for you for having the patience to answer the survey! I had to laugh about the classification though! But who knows these days for sure! I love caller ID too but every so often hubby will answer the calls just to get them from stopping calling. We tend to get a lot of calls for different people that had the number before us who are having problems with debts and collection agencies call a lot. Those I'll try to answer if they leave a message so they can remove this number from their list trying to get a hold of that person.

    betty

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. My poor son had an awful time with his cell phone number the first few years. He would never answer, but the collection agencies left messages for the previous number owner on a weekly basis. I finally called back and told them they had the wrong number and that they needed to stop harassing a minor.

      Delete
  4. Well, I'm glad I got your gender right, Bijoux. Sounds like you got a real zombie on the other end of the line.

    You are so right about the so-called Do Not Call Registry. I'm getting more annoying phones than ever.

    Let us know if you decide to change genders.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. We get at least four hang ups per day, though sometimes the robocallers leave messages.

      I'll keep you posted if I decided to make any changes.

      Delete
  5. The surveyors are indeed robotic, but they have to be. It skews the results if they vary from the script - they need to know they get answers in response to precisely the same questions for validity's sake. Science is not always user friendly.

    Did you hear about facebook adding all the new choices for gender identity? Maybe this particular study is also going to code for the effect of perceived gender in addition to biological sex?

    I get calls every day from what I presume to be a robo-caller in Pomona, CA. I never answer. In fact, I don't answer my phone at all ever unless I recognize the caller.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I also wonder if survey takers are influenced by what they perceive as hostile surveyors? I understand that they can't be Joe Friendly and go off script, but a little warmth is appreciated by most and would probably get more honesty. JMO

      I usually don't answer, but will sometimes pick up if it's before 9 a.m., thinking it MUST be an emergency, but of course, I'm fooled.

      Delete
    2. Most surveys I'm not interested in, as they're just marketing-type exercises, but I did take part in the British Crime Survey some time ago because I thought it was a useful project.

      I get really annoyed with those cold callers you can never get rid of because they never disclose their phone numbers. The moment I get a strange voice on the line, I just hang up.

      I don't see why they ask for your birth gender. Surely all that matters is what gender you define yourself as right now?

      Delete
    3. If someone wants my opinion, I'm happy to give it. The whole birth gender thing was just weird. I wouldn't be surprised if some people hang up, thinking a question like that is a prank.

      Delete
  6. with some of the weirdo's around here, those would have been legitimate questions - (although i doubt half of them would know the answer)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Your comment made me laugh, but yes, there are some confused folks out there!

      Delete
  7. Well, you know those tranny bong-smokers might just skew the survey. . .

    And you know, if 2 puffs is all it takes, maybe I really DID toke up back in the day. . .

    ReplyDelete
  8. truth be told, i tried my first legitimate cigarette at age 29 and my first cigar at 30. and, well, that was all. i'm actually considering finding either a mild pipe mix or a mild cigar for working in the garden as the smoke annoys the bugs. i didn't believe it until I went golfing with a buddy and we were swarmed until he lit up on the second hole. really cleared the air, so to speak.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I don't advise taking up smoking. Can't you just burn some tobacco in a lantern or something?

      Better yet, Avon sells that Skin Be Soft lotion........hahaha.......I'm working hard at amusing myself here at 1:15 am.

      Delete
    2. bijoux- not considering taking it up, just using it for defense. unfortunately tobacco seems to need a consistent source of forced oxygen to burn effectively. no worries, though, i only spend a couple hours a week in the garden.

      Delete
  9. That makes me wonder if that was a prank or at least not really from the CDC. Just seems like an odd survey for a government to employ. Glad to see you have remained female through the whole debacle!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm certain it was real because of the letter ahead of time. And she did wait till the end of the call to ask those questions. It just seemed dumb to ask to speak to the oldest female in the household and then question me about being a female at the end.

      Delete
  10. I guess now that there are 50 billion ways you can identify yourself on Facebook, they're just trying to keep up with the times. Ironically, I had to call my healthcare provider last night to schedule an appointment, and was given a similar batch of self-identity questions. Go figure...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Well now, THAT is interesting!!! Did you laugh?

      Delete
    2. I did. I mean, what else COULD I do?

      Delete
  11. Wow. I hope they pay those surveyors well. Think of how annoyed you were by the end of the questioning, but can you imagine asking those same crazy questions ALL DAY LONG??? Madness. And really, what point does it all serve? Silliness.

    But your husbands line makes it all worth it. ;)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I always imagine people in those jobs sitting in a big room with others performing that job and talking about the crazy people during their breaks.

      My husband always knows how to humor me.

      Delete
  12. It's pretty amazing, really, that care with language has progressed to such levels. I hope your gender suited your husband well when he got home.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment