I have mixed feelings about this book. First, it's a difficult read due to the subject matter. The story opens with the 5th birthday of a boy who you soon learn is imprisoned in a room with his mother, who was kidnapped at age 19. The boy's father is the abductor. Room (an 11 x 11 foot shed, if I'm remembering correctly) is the only home the boy has ever known. Everything he has learned has been from his mother and television. I grew a little tired of hearing about Dora the Explorer and the other things the boy perseverated on (such as breastfeeding), but I suppose the author was trying to convey what it felt like to be the mother, who had never been apart from the child for one minute in five years. Without giving too much away, I will also say I didn't think the author did her job on researching therapy. I found it odd that the therapists/clinic workers didn't seem to be aware that the boy wouldn't understand things like euphemisms and social cues, due to his severe isolation. I'm sure most people would like this book (and the movie), but it just wasn't my thing.
Let me know if you've read any good books lately! |
I've got a big pile of books in my 'to read' pile, but not a lot of time just now to read them. A couple of the more interesting titles on the top of the pile - These Beautiful Bones: An Everyday Theology of the Body by Emily Stimpson, and The Benedict Option by Rod Dreher.
ReplyDeleteAs you have noted before, our tastes in books tend to run in very different channels. . . ;)
No, I don't suppose we would ever join the same book club.
DeleteBurnt Toast sounds like it would be best as a book and not as breakfast! :)
ReplyDeleteThe title comes from something the author's grandmother used to say. She refused to buy a toaster and managed to always burn the toast in the oven.
DeleteAvoiding processed food and telling all how is a win indeed. But can be tough, reading about some making due would really open the eyes of those who whine they are broke, when really they aren't.
ReplyDeleteYes, many people don't truly understand how to stretch a dollar. The kitchen school book was really interesting and got me to decide to make my own salad dressings instead of buying the bottles. So much cheaper, better for you, and tastes better, too.
DeleteI didn't read the first one you mentioned (The Book Thief), however, I did watch several clips on the movie version and I was immediately pulled into the story. For some reason, I am very drawn to that time period (WW2). I even performed in the play version of The Diary of Anne Frank, which was during that time period in history.
ReplyDeleteLove the book cover of the second book. And I also love the title! Seems like a very enjoyable read.
The last book kind of reminds me of the book/movie, Flowers in the Attic.
Thanks again for sharing your book reviews, my friend! Thoroughly enjoyed!
X
Ron, I think WW2 is probably the most popular time period for books in general. SO many books out there about it. I think people are interested in it because it was so horrific, yet not that long ago. It's crazy to think our parents lived through it.
DeleteI read Room some time ago. I can see that it's a brilliant feat of imagination, depicting two people in a situation far removed from everyday life. But I didn't enjoy it, I think because it was so relentlessly negative until the final pages where Jack's mother is regaining a sense of independence and Jack has emotionally left the Room behind him.
ReplyDeleteOh, I'm glad to hear from someone else who read it. Wasn't the constant breastfeeding talk from Jack weird?
DeleteAbout 4 yeas ago, I blogged about the escape of 3 women here who had been held against their wills for a decade. One changed her name and doesn't talk to anyone. The other two wrote a book, and one of those does a missing person segment on the local news station. It's interesting how they have adjusted differently.
I just got done reading Blood Red Kiss, an anthology by three authors that I love. I'll be reviewing it soon on my blog. I haven't read any of the books you listed.
ReplyDeleteYou like those dark novels!
DeleteI've not read any of these. I can't imagine any therapist worth her or his salt not understanding how that sort of social deprivation would hinder a kid.
ReplyDeleteMaybe the author as just trying to portray the boy's lack of social understanding by having the therapist treat him like an average child? I'm not sure, but it was weird. The whole second half of the book didn't seem realistic to me. Such as, why would a clinic allow the mother free access to meds the week after she escapes? Dumb!
DeleteI like Kristin Hannah as an author. Right now I can't remember the book I was reading from her a few years back (I blogged about it) but the book was so intriguing it made me burn the potatoes I was cooking for potato salad the next day; completely forgot they were cooking). I did read the Nightingale and enjoyed it immensely.
ReplyDeleteI am intrigued by the stories from WW2 and the Holocaust and read as many fictional books as I can from that era. It dawned on me about a year or so ago that my dad, (Polish born and raised until he immigrated to the States after the war) lived in those conditions I read about. He was in a work camp run by the Nazis having been in the Polish army and captured. Never talked too much about his experiences and died when I was really young. Don't know if he would have talked more if he had lived and we were older.
Anyway, lately I've been reading a series of books about WW2 etc from Roberta Kagan. The first one I read was All My Love Detrick, the second You are My Sunshine, Just starting the third one Promised Land. So far still intrigued.
betty
Wow, that is so interesting about your father! I had some uncles that fought in WW2, but don't know any stories other than ones about fighting the Japanese. Are any of your dad's siblings still alive that you could ask?
DeleteYou would probably enjoy reading The Book Thief!
I remember I always wanted to see The Book Thief when it was in the movies or once it came out on video. I never did, and then forgot about it. Now I'll have to check if it's on Netflix or Amazon Prime. Thanks for the reminder!
ReplyDeleteI know, books are usually better...but I don't want to wait until I retire. LOL.
I don't generally watch movies, but I hope it's a good one.
DeleteI have been meaning to read The Book Thief forever. I should really get around to it. It has already been made into a movie. Apparently the movie was pretty good too.
ReplyDeleteSomeone recommended the book ROOM to me before but it just seemed too dark and sad. I read to escape this crazy world. I don't want anymore trauma. ;)
I would definitely read The Book Thief and skip Room then!
DeleteAnd here I'm all like:
ReplyDeletehttps://www.ibm.com/support/knowledgecenter/SSB27U_6.4.0/com.ibm.zvm.v640.pdf/pdf.htm
I'm sure I'd be at the edge of my seat.
DeleteHey, it's free as free can be! just don't drive afterwards, i won't be responsible for the lingering mental fog ....
DeleteBurnt toast apparently does not make you a grammar whiz, though. But it sounds like an interesting read, as do the others. Keep the recommendations coming!
ReplyDeleteI'm reading Northanger Abbey right now, but probably not your cup of tea!
DeleteI know I wouldn't want to even touch the "Room" one, but "Burnt Toast Makes You Sing Good" might be a winner. I have such nostalgia for the golden age of the middle class during the post-war era, an odd thing given that I wasn't even around when it happened. Some part of me has long wished I'd been able to grow up in the 1970s.
ReplyDeleteDude, from what I remember, the 70's were groovy, man!
DeleteThe Book Thief sounds intriguing, thanks for the tip. I've been reading mostly articles and short stories lately, but I'm itching to dive head first into a juicy novel.
ReplyDeleteIt's nice to escape into a novel.
Delete