Now For the Non-Fiction

And now for some memorable non-fiction from last year's reading log:



This was a book that, like me, had good intentions, but fell apart (which is why I gave up halfway through). Desmond attempts to paint a picture of how people living in poverty can't ever climb out, due to economic exploitation. Unfortunately, his case studies don't elicit much sympathy from the reader. I truly wanted to root for the underdog in these scenarios, but it was difficult, due to the cycle of drugs and violence. I seem to be mostly alone in my feelings about this book, because others found it eye opening and shocking. I've always lived in the Rust Belt, so maybe I'm jaded.

I'm a huge David Sedaris fan, and Crosley is the closest I've ever found to be a female version of him. Her essays on life are hilarious. This is her third book and might be her best. My favorite was 'Outside Voices' about Jared, a high schooler who lived in a neighboring townhouse. The way she conveys how annoyed she is by his loud social gatherings, while still wanting to be the 'cool' neighbor lady, describe the juxtaposition perfectly. So relatable!

Well, just shoot me. Someone recommended this book to me, and all I could think was, "How boring does this person think I am?" Early on, the author tries to make her point (see subtitle on book cover) by linking US News & World Report's college ranking system to the increase in college tuition since the mid-'80's. I call that a cause-effect fallacy, but I'm not a big data expert. Another minor annoyance: when discussing minimum wage workers, she describes what she terms a 'recent' phenomenon, "Clo-pening," where the same employee closes and then has to re-open the next day. First of all, I guess she's never held a minimum wage job, because that's been going on for at least the last 40 years. Her point is that it hurts people like single mothers (I don't dispute that), but O'Neil tries to turn it into a "product of data economy" and "efficiency-focused weapon of math destruction." When in all likelihood, schedules like that are devised because it's unfair to make some people close multiple times per week, while others get to work all the day shifts. I often feel as though there are those in academia who have lost touch with reality. The 30+ pages of citations didn't help either.

Is it possible to love a book, but despise the author whose life the book is based upon? Yes, it is! An odd book choice for me, but the topic was fascinating. Hop aboard and learn what it's like to be a 'bed bugger' (term used to describe a cross-country household mover). This guy has an overinflated ego, but he's a good writer. A highly educational and interesting read on a subject I knew nothing about.

Most people have heard of this book. It became popular after the last presidential election, as a sort of 'explanation' of Trump's appeal to factory workers (I never totally saw the connection after reading). My husband heard the author speak at a conference and told me about the book. This is another author who I would have zero interest in getting coffee with, but it was an insightful take on the segment of our population that we call 'hillbillies.' I did agree with Vance's point that in order to combat generational poverty, the key is having at least one adult take an interest in a child's life, whether that be an extended family member or a teacher. For Vance, that was his grandmother. I'd give the book an average rating.
 
 

Comments

  1. I haven't read any of these but then I mostly read paranormal romance these days.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I can't read anything with the supernatural in it. It freaks me out.

      Delete
  2. Yeah, some are so out of touch with reality as they stay in academia forever. One's like the first I may roll my eyes at a bit.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The 'economic exploitation' went like this: Slumlord rents dilapidated housing to single mom whose boyfriend comes over and gets into a fight with her and breaks all the windows. Slumlord sees the mess and kicks them out. Rinse and repeat. I found the book more exasperating than shocking.

      Delete
  3. For some reason, I've never read a lot of nonfiction. But The Long Haul does sound interesting. Son had a friend whose dad was a long truck hauler. Would be interesting to read this book and compare it to stories I heard from son's friend as well as friend's mom about "life on the road." Also, the book Look Alive Out There sounds interesting. Maybe I'll have to challenge myself to read one nonfiction for every 10 I read of fiction. I'm curious about Michelle Obama's book but I'll add it to the wait list at the library rather than buy it, though I did hear that she does donate a lot of the money earned on it to this or that.

    Thanks for the reviews!

    betty

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Betty, I think you'd enjoy the trucker book then. And you've done some big moves yourself, so I bet you'd find it very interesting. I can find most anything through my library system. It will even allow me to order from other systems in the state.

      Delete
  4. "I often feel as though there are those in academia who have lost touch with reality."

    Gee, ya think?

    But you know what Mark Twain said about the three kinds of lies. . .

    ReplyDelete
  5. Honestly, I think I would have felt like you about the first book. I have total compassion for anyone in genuine need, but not if they are not attempting to help themselves. Trust me, Philadelphia is filled with people who want everything handed to them by the government, while they do nothing.

    I like David Sedaris too, so I think I would really enjoy that second book, and well as the last one. I will look for them both the next time I'm in B&B.

    Great reviews, my friend! Thanks!
    X

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I wanted to like at least one of the case studies, but even the disabled guy was in a wheelchair because he fell asleep in a crack house and almost froze to death so had to have his feet removed. Crazy crap like that!

      Delete
  6. I will definitely look for Sloane Crossley because I adore Sedaris. I saw him do a reading once and laughed so hard I was crying. I read Hillbilly Elegy and really hoped I'd like that book. But didn't. Or rather, didn't like the author at all. I felt like he just washed over the violence and chaos of his upbringing with a "Yeah, but they're family!" pass.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I remember crying when I read one of Sedaris' stories for the first time. It involvef him becoming suspicious of the pervertedness of everyone he knew, including his mother, when she was measuring his inseam! Hilarious!

      Vance clearly has anger management issues, stemming from childhood. I feel sorry for his wife.

      Delete
  7. The long haul trucker sounds interesting. I have only heard of Hillbilly Elegy, and mixed reviews at that...

    www.thepulpitandthepen.com

    ReplyDelete
  8. It's official: "Weapons of Math Destruction" wins the award for Best Title EVER.

    (Had to comment again once I was signed in to my proper account!)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You would not feel that way if you read the book. Major snooze fest.

      Delete
  9. Replies
    1. I wouldn't like to be a trucker, but it was fun to ride along on his adventures.

      Delete
  10. Hey, Bijoux, great selection. Thanks for sharing them with us. I confess the only title I recognize is "Hillbilly Elegy," which I have not read. I'm sure getting some fabulous book ideas from you.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I haven't read or heard of any of these books, but The Long Haul sounds intriguing - if only because I've moved so many times and such great distances. Sure, leave it to you to make me worry about one more thing about moving: getting bed bugs from a moving truck!

    And all I want to say about the Weapons of Math Destruction is that "data" is plural and therefore, it should read "How big data increase inequality..." Hrrrmmmpppfff.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. OMG....LOL, that is such a good catch on the grammar! You are right!

      And don't worry, the bed bugger term is just a nickname; nothing in the book suggested the trucks carried the critters.

      Delete
  12. Fiction is more fun ...... though my fiction would not be yours. Then again, mine is not much.

    As you hint, non-fiction I've read is often written by someone out of touch with society (er, reality) who has a message to convey but fails either in execution (point relatively easily refuted) or in vanity (my experience is, obviously, your experience. And ain't I awesome?).

    I'll stick with my technical manuals ;-)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I have read some great non-fiction in the past, but sadly, not much recently. Enjoy your tech manuals!

      Delete

Post a Comment